Production of the original Back to the Future was marred by a bit of controversy, which arose when actor Eric Stoltz, who had been hired to portray Marty McFly, was let go from production several weeks in. Replaced by Michael J. Fox, it was a situation that the acclaimed Stoltz deals with to this day. In the second part of Edward Gross’ exclusive interview with writer/producer Bob Gale, the details around the situation are revealed.
VOICES FROM KRYPTON: The one disappointment for me about the DVD box set was that we didn’t get to see any of the Eric Stoltz footage.
BOB GALE: Well, I’ll explain that to you, because Bob and I had a long talk about that. And I was actually lobbying to get just one scene in there, without any dialogue, just of him walking around the back lot. We reviewed the footage, and Bob said “Look, this is not going to do Eric any good, it’s going to make him look really bad, and he went through enough pain over this movie that I don’t want to hurt him again.” Then he said, “Quite frankly, it makes me look bad for casting him in the first place.” We saved the footage, we actually had the opportunity to destroy the negative, and destroy it all, and we talked about it, but we decided we shouldn’t destroy it, because it is a rare historical opportunity to have this, but I think we all need to be in our 60s before we release this to the world.
VOICES FROM KRYPTON: It’s interesting, because at one point Eric Stoltz was interviewed by the Saturday Today Show, and Jody Applegate asked him about Back to the Future, something along the lines of, “How did it feel?” and he just looked at her with anger in his eyes, and said, “What an insensitive question to ask somebody.”
BOB GALE: Well, it is an insensitive question. It’s like you see those newspaper reporters going up to someone after a tragedy and asking, “How did you feel when you heard your family was killed?” “Well, screw you!”
VOICES FROM KRYPTON: I guess knowing these movies so well, it’s a natural curiosity to wonder how someone else would have tackled the role…
BOB GALE: And we understand that, we’re aware of it, but there’s a human cost. There’s no reason to cause pain, and that’s why we didn’t do it.